In fantasy football, the decision to hold or sell a player of Christian McCaffrey’s caliber is like playing a complex game of chess. Without a doubt, McCaffrey stands out as a monumental force in fantasy leagues. Underlined by a stellar career that has contained unmatched accomplishments. Yet, as we peak into his future, there’s a growing sentiment that now might make today the moment to sell. Especially for teams not firmly in the championship hunt.
Christian McCaffrey’s fantasy impact is nothing short of legendary. Excluding his injury-shortened seasons and rookie season where he still dazzled with 230 PPR (points per reception) fantasy points, McCaffrey has never performed below the 350 fantasy point threshold in a full season. This is a testament to his capability, consistently over 1,000 rushing yards and at least 500 receiving yards every season. His ability to dominate both the ground and air makes him a rare talent in fantasy football. He is a player who can single-handedly tilt the balance of power in any game, both fantasy and real life.
Despite these accolades, storm clouds loom in the form of injury concerns and the inevitable advance of age. Approaching 28, McCaffrey finds himself at a crossroads; his history of injuries casting a shadow of doubt over his durability. Even the San Francisco 49ers, a team that has heavily relied on his exceptional talents, have planned to lighten his workload in 2023 to mitigate the risk of further injuries. This move speaks volumes about the serious considerations teams must take regarding player longevity. Particularly at the Running Back position in the bruising environment of the NFL.
For dynasty managers, the gameplan is clear: if you’re gunning for the championship this year, McCaffrey is an indispensable asset. His proven track record and game-changing performances make him a cornerstone for any contender.
However, for teams on the fringes of contention or in the beginning of a rebuild, the proposition is significantly different. The smart play should very well be to sell high on McCaffrey now. His performance history and still-potent capabilities can command a king’s ransom in trade, offering the chance to secure valuable future assets that can fuel a team’s long-term success.
The essence of dynasty fantasy football lies in navigating the delicate balance between winning now and building for the future. Christian McCaffrey, with all his talent and his injury history, represents one of the most intriguing dilemmas for managers. As such, the decision to hold or sell McCaffrey delves into the strategic foresight required to sustain success in the ever-evolving landscape of dynasty fantasy football.
Related Content:
For Part 24 of our “Does It Matter?” series, we investigated whether Relative Athletic Score (RAS) can be a predictor of success
In Part 23 of our “Does It Matter?” series, we look into the question of whether weight can be a predictor of
For part 22 of our “Does It Matter?” series, we looked into the often debated topic of height and its impact on
