As the NFL draft looms, teams and fantasy football owners alike are analyzing prospects such as JJ McCarthy. Despite his tenure at a powerhouse like Michigan, McCarthy emerges as a prospect where our main critique lies within the numbers. Let’s dive into why his collegiate stats may wave cautionary flags for his transition to the professional level.
At first glance, McCarthy’s tenure at Michigan is solid but lacks the jaw-dropping statistics fantasy owners value. In 2022, he threw for 2,719 yards, logged 22 touchdowns against 5 interceptions. He slightly improved in 2023 with 2,991 yards, 22 touchdowns, and reduced interceptions to 4. While these numbers are respectable, they don’t jump off the page. This performance labels him as more of a “game manager” rather than a statistical powerhouse.
Fantasy Football owners are always on the lookout for the next league dominator. A quarterback who can single-handedly sway the tide of weekly matchups with explosive plays and jaw-dropping stat lines. McCarthy’s college career might not be the indicative of that future. The challenge lies in projecting his potential for fantasy relevance amidst a history of quarterbacks with similarly unspectacular collegiate careers who managed to find their stride in the NFL.
Kirk Cousins’ career arc offers a compelling comparison for how we predict McCarthy’s NFL journey. Like McCarthy, Cousins faced his share of skepticism coming out of college. The early years of his career with the Washington Redskins held a lot of high scrutiny and sporadic performance. This culminated in the team’s decision to part ways in favor of Alex Smith. This was a move signaling their reluctance to bank on Cousins as their franchise quarterback. Despite these challenges, Cousins carved out a successful career trajectory, a testament to the unpredictability between player potential and the right circumstances.
Drawing parallels between Cousins and McCarthy suggests a potential roadmap for McCarthy’s career, albeit one with hurdles. Success in the NFL often hinges on a combination of factors – from team fit and coaching to personal development. For McCarthy, the skepticism rooted in his “game manager” reputation could either be a stumbling block or a footnote in a career that defies the odds.
In conclusion, while JJ McCarthy’s collegiate stats might raise red flags for fantasy owners, history reminds us that the leap from college to pro can be both unpredictable and transformational. As McCarthy prepares to make that jump, only time will tell whether he follows in the footsteps of quarterbacks like Cousins. Therefore turning skepticism into a storied NFL career.
*Predict the 2026 Super Bowl winner on the product page for a full refund! No catches or extra fees to participate!* What 3 metrics matter the most when scouting a rookie Quarterback? What threshold should Quarterbacks achieve within those metrics to be considered an elite prospect? How much should you value those stats above all other stats? Couldn't answer those questions? Rest easy, we have it handled for you. That's what this chart answers. Sort by importance and/or filter by position. Unlock by signing up with the links provided. $9.99/Year or $24.99 Lifetime access. Cancel anytime.
For our 61 part “Does It Matter?” series, we looked into whether a Wide Receiver’s College Yards After Catch per Reception (YAC/Rec)
In part 60 of our “Does It Matter?” series, we dove into the question of whether a college Wide Receiver’s career Average
The “Does It Matter?” series, part 59 looked to uncover the role of a quarterback’s rookie touchdown per game (TD/G) in predicting
© 2023 BrainyBallers | All Rights Reserved
